Whole Network Most Recent TOP10 Biotech Business Energy Investing

 

How to rig a nanotech survey

Filed in archive Government by george elvin on January 03, 2006

BlogPicture
SF Gate, the online version of the San Francisco Chronicle, recently asked its readers, " Should the state plow billions into the nanotechnology vision? " Here are the results:

-- Yes. The dividend includes tax dollars and jobs in the long run. 17%
-- No. A billion- or trillion-dollar industry doesn't need our ante. 41%
-- Good idea. But get industry to put the payback in writing. 41%
I love a misleading survey question as much as the next person, but what if instead of asking,

" Should the state plow billions into the nanotechnology vision? "

they had asked,

" Should the state invest a small portion of its revenues in nanotechnology to accelerate its multi-billion dollar economic benefits? "

This is another case of the question' s format predetermining the answer. Also, a simple yes or no answer is the only way to ensure credible results. Adding commentary like, " a billion- or trillion-dollar industry doesn't need our ante, " is sure to prejudice respondents. And what' s the point of adding, " get industry to put the payback in writing " ? Who is " industry " ? And so what if they put it in writing? As I recall we had something in writing from the savings and loan industry prior to the multi-billion dollar bailout taxpayers are still footing the bill for.

I suppose SF gatelinks polls are done tongue-in-cheek anyway, or they are, like USA Today polls, engineered to support predetermined points of view rather than provide meaningful data. But tongue-in-cheek or not, the result is a poll suggesting that Californians reject the idea of spending tax revenues on nanotechnology. Michael Crighton will no doubt cite it as " scientific evidence " in his next novel.


Advertisement


Permalink: How to rig a nanotech survey
Tags: nanotechnology  nanotech 

Trackback: http://www.creative-weblogging.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.pl/13194



Advertisement


Advertisement


CW ToolbarInstall
RSSrss   | See all blog subscribe options
Googlegoogle   |   What is RSS?
Yahoo!yahoo
AddthisAddThis Feed Button
BloglinesBloglines
Newsletter
Advertisement - Book yours here.

Use our search feature to look for other interesting posts

Just this blog Whole network
Advertisement -
Book yours here..


 
Advertisement
Book yours here.



  • Other blogs in the same channel in the Creative Weblogging Network

Advertisement -
Book yours here..






Advertisement - Book yours here..
 
Tagcloud: Biotech Business Computing & Infotech Design Energy Environment & Health Events Government Institutions Investing Links Materials Medical Military News Products Regulation Research Society & Ethics Theory